PODCAST EPISODE 214

What 1,400 SEOs Claim Gets You Mentioned in AI Search

A survey of 1,400 professional SEOs ranked the factors that help a website get mentioned in AI search. Respondents were given a fixed list of factors and asked to score each one. The survey came from a source without a high-authority reputation in the SEO world, but high-authority companies in the industry are now paying attention to the results, which makes the list worth reviewing.

If you want to be in AI, you need to have good SEO.

What did the survey of 1,400 SEOs find helps websites appear in AI search?

The survey ranked ten leading factors, plus two additional factors that respondents considered much less important. The ten leading factors, in ranked order, are listed below with a plain-language translation of each.

  1. AI crawl access and snippet eligibility: AI systems must be allowed to access and use the content on a website.
  2. Query answer match: The content on a website needs to answer the specific questions people ask in AI tools.
  3. Brand entity in LLM memory: A brand that was part of an AI model's training data appears more often.
  4. Citable and specific facts: Facts, figures, names, and dates give AI something concrete to cite.
  5. Organic fan out coverage rankings: A website that already ranks in Google for questions related to the one asked in AI is treated as more of an authority.
  6. Organic search ranking: Strong rankings in Google carry over to mentions in AI.
  7. Unique first party information: Original information that no other website has, such as the results of a survey, helps a site stand out.
  8. Cross-web consensus and corroboration: Other websites and review platforms discussing a business in a positive way builds its reputation.
  9. Source and publisher reputation: The overall reputation of a business across the web influences how AI treats its content.
  10. Extractable content structure: Content that is easy for AI to read and reuse in its own answers is more likely to be used.

Why does AI crawl access rank first, and does it matter for most websites?

AI crawl access ranks first largely because of how the survey was built. Respondents scored a list of factors rather than answering an open-ended question about what matters most. A website that blocks AI will not appear in AI search, so this factor was always likely to score highly.

Blocking AI from a website takes deliberate effort. For that reason, nearly every website owner can treat this factor as already handled.

Good SEO carries over naturally into AI results.

Which factors can a business owner act on directly?

Five of the ten factors can be addressed through the content and reputation of a website. These are query answer match, citable and specific facts, unique first party information, extractable content structure, and reputation across the web.

Brand entity in LLM memory is much harder to influence. A brand generally needs to be large and authoritative before an AI model is trained on it, so this factor is out of reach for most small businesses.

Do organic rankings affect whether a website is mentioned in AI search?

Organic rankings do affect AI mentions, and the overlap between SEO and AI search is substantial. Google has said that a website must be in its index to appear in AI results, which means good SEO comes first.

Websites that perform well in SEO tend to be mentioned more often in AI as a natural result. This pattern has appeared with consulting clients and with students.

How should content be written and structured for AI to use it?

Content should be structured the way AI structures its own answers. That structure makes it easier for AI to parse a page and pull information from it into a response.

Specific, citable information also helps. Facts, figures, names, and dates give AI material it can attribute to a source, and original information gives a website something that other websites do not have.

A common example is a blog post titled "how to photograph" a particular subject or "top 10 tips" for photographing it. Posts like these exist by the thousands, so a post needs something unique to separate it from the rest.

Structure your content the same way AI structures its own answers.

Do structured data and llms.txt help with AI search?

Structured data and the llms.txt file showed very little evidence of helping, and the SEOs surveyed rated them as unimportant. Both may matter a little. Adding them does no harm when the process is easy, but both are technical and may not be worth the effort when the process is difficult.

On a WordPress website, both are possible to implement. The AI and SEO crash course explains how to decide whether either one is worth doing.

What is the practical takeaway from the survey?

The survey is useful when read as a whole, and two takeaways stand out. The first is that SEO and AI search overlap heavily, so a website needs good SEO to appear in AI. The second is that specific, citable information and a structure that is easy for AI to use make a measurable difference in how often a website is mentioned.

The exact order of the list should not be treated as a strict sequence of steps. Optimizing for AI is still new, and the factors are likely to change over time. A respondent from HubSpot commented that the survey results will age poorly, which reflects how early the field still is.

For step-by-step instructions on putting these factors into practice on a website, the AI and SEO crash course includes about two and a half hours of video tutorials.

Meredith’s Husband is an SEO consultant with over 20 years of experience helping small businesses grow through clear, practical search strategies. He hosts Meredith’s Husband: SEO for People Who Don’t Like SEO alongside Meredith, a professional photographer, where they break down SEO and AI visibility using real-world examples from working businesses.
- Chris Dawkins, SEO consultant since 2002
Created with