PODCAST EPISODE 216

How to Find the Questions to Answer on Your Website

If your website traffic has dropped, or your inquiries have slowed, it's easy to think, "It feels like Google hates me." It's not that Google hates you. A drop in traffic rarely has one cause, so there is rarely one thing to undo.

The most useful place to start is with the questions your customers are already asking. This post shows you how to find those questions, how to answer them on your website, and how to tell whether the answers are getting seen. It's the same approach I would use if I were starting over with a new website, or if my own traffic was declining.

The approach takes time. It doesn't need a year of planning, and it doesn't promise a result by a certain date.

Start with the questions your customers already ask

Your own inbox is the best source of questions. Look through the emails, inquiry form messages and calls from clients and prospects, and write down every question you've answered more than once. Those questions are real, they come from people who are interested in what you do, and you already know the answers.

For example, a photographer's clients might ask, "What should we wear for winter engagement photos?" That question has one person, one situation and one clear answer.

Google Search Console can add to your list. Under Performance, the search results report lists the searches that already show your pages in Google. Any question that appears there is a question people already connect with your site.

By answering specific questions, your answers will match with a specific search.

Choose narrow questions over broad topics

Narrow questions work better than broad topics. In my opinion, narrow beats broad, and that isn't new advice. My topic is SEO, so "how to do SEO" is the first keyword that comes to mind, but it's very broad. If I tried to rank for it, I would be competing with huge websites that I could never outrank.

A narrow question has far fewer websites competing for it. On my own site, I answer questions as specific as "How do I fix the duplicate title tag issue in Semrush?" I've been doing that for several years, and it has worked very well for me.

A narrow question also tells you who is asking. Someone asking about duplicate title tags in Semrush is already trying to do SEO, and that's the person I teach. In the same way, someone asking what to wear for winter engagement photos is already planning photos.

The trade is a smaller audience and less visibility. The visibility you do get is with the people you want to reach, so a larger share of them should become customers.

Write one post for each question

Each post should answer one question, and only one. Put the answer in the first few sentences, then add the details a person would want next. Use the question, in your customer's own words, as the title or as a heading, so the post matches the way people ask.

A year's worth of planned questions isn't necessary. Start with a handful of posts, then see which ones get the most visibility.

A smaller audience might mean less visibility, but better visibility with your target audience.

Check which posts are getting seen

The generative AI report in Google Search Console shows how your pages appear in AI searches. The report is hidden, so it's easy to miss. On the left side of the screen, find Performance, click the small caret next to it, and the generative AI report is listed underneath.

Look at which of your posts, and which questions, are getting the most visibility. Use those results to choose your next questions. If one broader question is getting attention, write posts that answer the smaller questions inside it next.

The report has one limit: it only shows information from Google. It doesn't show how people search in ChatGPT or Claude. SEOs have lived with this for years, because other search engines such as Bing, Yahoo and DuckDuckGo don't have tools like Search Console. The working assumption is that people ask ChatGPT and Claude questions similar to the ones they ask Google.

Fix the basics that may be holding your site back

Make sure nothing technical is holding your website back. If you have never checked, there will be things to fix, through no fault of your own. That's just the way websites are.

Technical SEO is the behind-the-scenes setup that helps Google read your site. Duplicate page titles are one example. Pages Google can't reach, broken pages, and a site that's hard to use on a phone are others.

There will always be things to fix. That's just the websites are.

What to expect

Expect this work to take time. I can't promise a result by a certain date, and I can't tell you what Google or any AI platform will do next. What you can control is the work itself: answering real questions, checking what gets seen, and keeping the basics clean.

Summary: Three Things to Do When Your Traffic Declines

  • Answer narrow questions with your content. A post built around one specific question brings the people who already want what you offer.
  • Monitor your impressions. The generative AI report in Google Search Console shows how your pages appear in AI searches.
  • Keep your basics clean. A website that has never been checked will have technical SEO issues to fix.

Resources

  • Outline of the mentoring program

To see what keeping your technical SEO clean looks like, read the outline of the mentoring program on the mentoring overview page.


Meredith’s Husband is an SEO consultant with over 20 years of experience helping small businesses grow through clear, practical search strategies. He hosts Meredith’s Husband: SEO for People Who Don’t Like SEO alongside Meredith, a professional photographer, where they break down SEO and AI visibility using real-world examples from working businesses.
- Chris Dawkins, SEO consultant since 2002
Created with