PODCAST EPISODE 217
Why Your Website Stopped Getting Leads From Google
You used to get inquiries through Google without thinking about it. Then they slowed down, and you can't figure out why. If you've caught yourself saying "It feels like Google hates me" or "I've tried everything," this post is for you.
Here is the direct answer. When a website stops getting leads from Google, the cause is very rarely one thing you did wrong. It's usually a pile of small problems that built up over time, plus one or two quick checks that can rule out a single cause.
Why one mistake rarely explains lost Google leads
Think of search rankings as a brick house. No single brick turns a pile of bricks into a house, and taking one brick out of a finished house usually changes very little. A drop in rankings or impressions (the number of times your website appears in Google results) is very rarely the result of one brick going missing. More often, a whole bunch of bricks are out of place.
Still, the urge to find that one brick is human nature. You had leads, now you don't, and you want to know what you did wrong. So you go back through your website and ask whether you changed a keyword or moved an image.
You undo one change, then check whether your Google traffic and rankings come back. Often nothing happens. Meanwhile, fewer inquiries arrive, which means fewer clients and less revenue, and everything feels more stressful.

Three habits that keep website owners stuck
Three common reactions can turn a traffic drop into a longer problem.
- Fixing one thing at a time. You change a keyword, rewrite a page title, or swap an image, then wait to see whether Google traffic returns.
- Blogging more of the same. Because your blog used to bring in visitors, you publish more posts on the same topics. If those posts are part of what caused the decline, more of them can make it worse.
- Trusting quick-fix promises. Some SEO agencies promise to work out what happened and get your rankings back fast. That promise is usually marketing, and you can end up with money spent and the same problem.

Four checks to run when your website stops getting leads from Google
Work through these checks in order. The first two can rule out a single cause. The last two cover the slower, many-brick problems.
1. Check that your contact form works
Fill out your own website's contact form, then confirm that the message reached your inbox. Check your spam folder too. A broken contact form cuts off every lead, so nothing else on your website matters until the form works.
When a new client tells me their Google leads stopped months ago, this is the first thing I test. Sometimes the form has been broken the whole time. It isn't the most common cause, but it is a big one when it happens. Any leads that tried to come through during that time are lost unless a backup exists.
To protect yourself, connect your contact form to a backup. On WordPress, most contact form plugins can send each submission to a Google Sheet. That way, a copy of every lead is stored even if email delivery fails.
2. Look for a sudden drop in Google Search Console
Google Search Console is a free tool from Google that shows how your website appears in Google search results. If you don't have an account yet, ask an AI assistant how to set up Google Search Console on your website platform, such as WordPress or Squarespace.
In Google Search Console, open the Performance report and set the date range to the longest one available. Look for one steep fall, roughly a 50 percent drop within a week or two. A fall like that more often points to a single mistake. A slow downhill slope is a different problem, covered in the next check.
The most common cause of a sudden drop is changing page URLs, such as the web addresses of your pages. It often happens during a website relaunch, or after advice to put keywords in the URL. I've seen it happen several times.
Say a photographer changes the address of her portrait page from /portraits to /family-portrait-photographer, hoping the keywords will help. The old address no longer exists, and whatever search authority that page had disappears with it.
The fix is a 301 redirect, a small instruction that tells visitors and Google, "This page moved, and here is the new address." To set one up, ask an AI assistant how to create a 301 redirect on your website platform.
3. If your traffic declined slowly, review your blog posts
A slow decline in traffic or impressions usually has a different cause. When traffic drops, publishing more blog posts feels like the obvious fix. But if the new posts repeat topics your blog already covers, publishing more of them can deepen the decline and make it harder to reverse.
Instead, review each blog post on your website and ask whether it is valuable. Every blog post should contribute something new. A post that only repackages what you've already written, or what other websites have already said, needs attention.
- Revise it if the post has a useful idea but weak content.
- Combine it if two posts say the same thing. Pick one URL to keep, move the best content from the other post into it, delete the other post, and set up a 301 redirect from the deleted address to the one you kept.
- Remove it if the post is outdated, such as a post about a time-sensitive event from years ago. Redirect its address to your main blog page.
Any time a URL changes or disappears, create a 301 redirect. That helps prevent the page's search value from being lost.
4. Check your technical website health
Technical problems can also hold a website back. Two places to look are a Semrush site audit and Google Search Console. In Google Search Console, confirm that Google is reading your sitemap, which is a file that lists the pages of your website, and that your pages are being indexed. Indexed means Google has added the page to the list of pages it can show in search results.
The Sitemaps report and the Pages report in Google Search Console are the places to look. This check has more steps than fit in one blog post, but those two reports are a solid place to start.

How long it takes to recover from a slow decline in Google traffic
Expect recovery to take about as long as the decline did. If Google Search Console shows your impressions sliding steadily over 12 months, plan on roughly 12 months to reverse it. That is a rough rule from my own work, not a promise, and it is often shorter, though not by a huge margin.
That can be hard to hear. If a website has been neglected for a year, there is no easy button, and snapping your fingers won't undo the result. Steady work on the four checks above is the way forward.

Summary: Four Checks to Run When Your Google Leads Drop
A drop in Google leads is very rarely caused by one thing. Check that your contact form works, look for a sudden drop in Google Search Console, review your blog posts if the decline was slow, and check your technical website health. Then give a slow decline the time it needs.
If you'd like help finding what's behind your own drop, you can book a strategy session with me, a single session where we look at those issues together: https://www.meredithshusband.com/course/consulting
Become an Insider
Thank you!
Check your inbox for confirmation
Get the SEO+AI Primer
Check Your Inbox!
Pleaase confirm your email address and receive the SEO+AI Primer course.
Check your INBOX and PROMOTIONS folders!
