PODCAST EPISODE 215

Unrealistic SEO Expectations and Declining Leads

Why does SEO feel like it stopped working?

SEO feels like it stopped working when a website that once produced a steady stream of leads from Google slowly produces fewer of them. The usual reaction is to look for a single cause and a quick repair. In most cases, neither exists.

A common request from business owners is an afternoon spent working out what went wrong. A more useful starting point is the website's Google Search Console data, which shows how impressions have changed over time.

What does a gradual decline in SEO leads actually mean?

A gradual decline in SEO leads means the problem built up over many months, not in one moment. Google Search Console shows up to 16 months of history, and declining impressions across six, 12, or 16 months are the typical pattern. That pattern points to a trend, not a single event.

Trends like this usually come from one issue stacking on top of another, then another. None of those issues is necessarily a mistake the website owner made. Each issue compounds the one before it, which is why the decline is slow and steady.

A sudden drop in traffic is different. A sudden drop can often be traced to a specific cause and undone in an afternoon. A year of declining leads cannot.

If you want a different outcome, you need to do something different.

How can you tell if your SEO expectations are unrealistic?

Unrealistic SEO expectations are likely present when SEO feels like it has been tried and does not work. A business owner who expects a quick result from SEO will be disappointed by definition, because the expectation itself cannot be met. Frustration follows naturally.

The good news is that this situation is very fixable, and the fix starts with a change in mindset. Changing expectations changes what a business owner chooses to do, and changing what gets done changes the outcome.

Expectations matter at the leadership level too. A CEO whose expectations stay unrealistic can undermine a project that is producing strong results, because no amount of explanation to the rest of the team changes the CEO's view.

Why does checking your Google rankings hurt more than it helps?

Checking Google rankings by hand is a misleading way to judge SEO performance. Searching for a website's position every day feels productive, but the results do not show whether SEO is working. A business owner who plans to check rankings daily is working against a sound SEO process.

Dropping the habit of checking rankings is the first step in resetting expectations.

Checking your ranking in google is the quickest way to ensure you are doomed.

What does it mean to trust the process in SEO?

Trusting the process means continuing the work long before the results are visible. SEO resembles building a brick house, where a large number of bricks go down before the structure looks like a house. Stopping after two bricks guarantees that no house gets built.

Getting in shape follows the same pattern. A person who has spent two years on the couch cannot expect the mirror to look different after two days at the gym. Reversing a long trend takes sustained effort over a comparable span of time.

How long does it take to recover from declining SEO leads?

A general rule of thumb is about a year to recover from a year of declining leads. The trend can be reversed sooner, and lead numbers can begin rising in the shorter term. Returning to the volume of a year earlier takes closer to the full year, not the first week or month.

You can't fix in a single afternoon, a problem that took years to develop.

What should you work on first when SEO leads are declining?

Improving the conversion rate is the best first practical step, whether leads are declining or SEO is only getting started. Conversion rate is the share of website visitors who become leads. Working on it means getting more leads from the traffic that already visits each month.

Conversion improvements can pay off quickly. A change that raises the conversion rate starts producing more leads from existing traffic the moment the change goes live. The real work is deciding which changes to make.

Together, the mindset shift and the conversion rate work form a short sequence:

  • Reset expectations: stop checking rankings and trust the process.
  • Set goals and a way to measure progress: define what success looks like before the work begins.
  • Improve the conversion rate: get more leads from the visitors already arriving.

This sequence matches the first two weeks of the SEO mentoring program. Week one covers mindset, goals, expectations, and measuring progress. Week two covers conversion rate and getting as many leads as possible from existing traffic.

Resources

  • Wait list for the next SEO mentoring program, which begins right after the holidays

Meredith’s Husband is an SEO consultant with over 20 years of experience helping small businesses grow through clear, practical search strategies. He hosts Meredith’s Husband: SEO for People Who Don’t Like SEO alongside Meredith, a professional photographer, where they break down SEO and AI visibility using real-world examples from working businesses.
- Chris Dawkins, SEO consultant since 2002

Why does SEO feel like it stopped working?

SEO feels like it stopped working when a website that once produced a steady stream of leads from Google slowly produces fewer of them. The usual reaction is to look for a single cause and a quick repair. In most cases, neither exists.

A common request from business owners is an afternoon spent working out what went wrong. A more useful starting point is the website's Google Search Console data, which shows how impressions have changed over time.

What does a gradual decline in SEO leads actually mean?

A gradual decline in SEO leads means the problem built up over many months, not in one moment. Google Search Console shows up to 16 months of history, and declining impressions across six, 12, or 16 months are the typical pattern. That pattern points to a trend, not a single event.

Trends like this usually come from one issue stacking on top of another, then another. None of those issues is necessarily a mistake the website owner made. Each issue compounds the one before it, which is why the decline is slow and steady.

A sudden drop in traffic is different. A sudden drop can often be traced to a specific cause and undone in an afternoon. A year of declining leads cannot.

If you want a different outcome, you need to do something different.

How can you tell if your SEO expectations are unrealistic?

Unrealistic SEO expectations are likely present when SEO feels like it has been tried and does not work. A business owner who expects a quick result from SEO will be disappointed by definition, because the expectation itself cannot be met. Frustration follows naturally.

The good news is that this situation is very fixable, and the fix starts with a change in mindset. Changing expectations changes what a business owner chooses to do, and changing what gets done changes the outcome.

Expectations matter at the leadership level too. A CEO whose expectations stay unrealistic can undermine a project that is producing strong results, because no amount of explanation to the rest of the team changes the CEO's view.

Why does checking your Google rankings hurt more than it helps?

Checking Google rankings by hand is a misleading way to judge SEO performance. Searching for a website's position every day feels productive, but the results do not show whether SEO is working. A business owner who plans to check rankings daily is working against a sound SEO process.

Dropping the habit of checking rankings is the first step in resetting expectations.

What does it mean to trust the process in SEO?

Trusting the process means continuing the work long before the results are visible. SEO resembles building a brick house, where a large number of bricks go down before the structure looks like a house. Stopping after two bricks guarantees that no house gets built.

Getting in shape follows the same pattern. A person who has spent two years on the couch cannot expect the mirror to look different after two days at the gym. Reversing a long trend takes sustained effort over a comparable span of time.

How long does it take to recover from declining SEO leads?

A general rule of thumb is about a year to recover from a year of declining leads. The trend can be reversed sooner, and lead numbers can begin rising in the shorter term. Returning to the volume of a year earlier takes closer to the full year, not the first week or month.

What should you work on first when SEO leads are declining?

Improving the conversion rate is the best first practical step, whether leads are declining or SEO is only getting started. Conversion rate is the share of website visitors who become leads. Working on it means getting more leads from the traffic that already visits each month.

Conversion improvements can pay off quickly. A change that raises the conversion rate starts producing more leads from existing traffic the moment the change goes live. The real work is deciding which changes to make.

Together, the mindset shift and the conversion rate work form a short sequence:

  • Reset expectations: stop checking rankings and trust the process.
  • Set goals and a way to measure progress: define what success looks like before the work begins.
  • Improve the conversion rate: get more leads from the visitors already arriving.

This sequence matches the first two weeks of the SEO mentoring program. Week one covers mindset, goals, expectations, and measuring progress. Week two covers conversion rate and getting as many leads as possible from existing traffic.

Resources

  • Wait list for the next SEO mentoring program, which begins right after the holidays

Meredith’s Husband is an SEO consultant with over 20 years of experience helping small businesses grow through clear, practical search strategies. He hosts Meredith’s Husband: SEO for People Who Don’t Like SEO alongside Meredith, a professional photographer, where they break down SEO and AI visibility using real-world examples from working businesses.
- Chris Dawkins, SEO consultant since 2002
Created with